MLRC Institute: Actions Against Online Speech

This list, maintained by the MLRC Institute, lists incidences in the United States in which online speech is threatened, whether through libel suits, criminal investigations, or other means. If you know of something we missed, please let us know. For more details on this list, see “Notes and Sources” below.

AdvanFort v. International Registires

›
AdvanFort v. International Registries (5/12/15) STATUS: Court grants motion to dismiss relating to section 230 defense. E.D.Va.: Online ...

Mezzacappa v. O'Hare

›
Mezzacappa v. O'Hare (March 31, 2015) STATUS: Court finds blogger not liable. Pa.Ct.Comm. Pleas.: Blogger Isn't Liable for Anon...

Yelp v. Hadeed Carpet Cleaning

›
Yelp v. Hadeed Carpet Cleaning (4/16/15) STATUS: Virginia Supreme Court rules in favor of Yelp. Virginia Supreme Court Won't Force Y...

Welch v. University of San Diego

›
Welch v. University of San Diego  (4/2/15) STATUS: Court rules in favor of anti-SLAPP lawsuit. Cal.App.: Law Professor Blogger Wins Anti...

Sletten v. Continental Casualty

›
Sletten v. Continental Casualty (March 19, 2015) STATUS: 8th Circuit finds in favor of insurer. 8th.Cir.: Insurer Doesn't Have to ...

Brannies v. Internet ROI

›
Brannies v. Internet ROI STATUS:  Federal Court finds website free of wrong doing. S.D. Ga.: Libel Claim Tossed Courthouse News A Mass...

Burdick v. Superior Court

›
Burdick v. Superior Court (1/14/15) STATUS:California Court of Appeals holds that there is no personal jurisdiction for case to move forwa...

Enjaian v. ALM Media

›
Enjaian v. ALM Media (12/23/14) STATUS:Court grants defendant's motion to strike. N.D.Cal.: Tweeted Article About Lawyer Facing Stal...

Brown v. Times-Picayune

›
Brown v. Times-Picayune (11/3/14) STATUS: Appellate court reverses lower court decision. La.App.: Appeals Court Reverses Dismissal of La...

Huon v. Breaking Media

›
Huon v. Breaking Media (12/4/14) STATUS: District Court will allow defamation claim. N.D. Ill.:  Legal Blog Faces Defamation Liability F...

Roca Lab v Does

›
Roca Labs v Does (11/14/14) STATUS: Suit filed in Circuit Court. Fla.Cir.: Roca Labs Sues Anonymous Commenters In Convoluted Plot To Ge...

Ringgold v. Radar Online

›
Ringgold v. Radar Online (11/6/14) STATUS: Complaint filed in Eastern District court. E.D.N.Y.: Radar Sullied Name of Tom Cruise Bodygua...

Concerned Citizens for Judicial Fairness v. Yacucci

›
Concerned Citizens for Judicial Fairness v. Yacucci (September 3, 2014) STATUS: Florida appeals court reverses lower court ruling. Fla.A...

Kinney v. Barnes

›
Kinney v. Barnes (August 29, 2014) STATUS: Texas court sets precedent by ruling that court can't stop republishing of defamatory cont...

Cornett v. Gawker Media

›
Cornett v. Gawker Media (August 28, 2014) STATUS: Federal judge refused order of early settlement. D. Nev.: Surfer Loses Bid to Settle ...

In re John Doe a.k.a "Trooper"

›
In re John Doe a.k.a "Trooper" (August 29, 2014) STATUS: Texas court will not out identity of anonymous blogger. Texas Supreme...

Mayfield v. Fullhart

›
Mayfield v. Fullhart (August 21, 2014) STATUS: Texas appellate court rules that single publication rule applies to the Internet. Tex.App...

Westlake Legal Group v. Schumacher

›
Westlake Legal Group v. Schumacher  (8/19/14) STATUS: Court dismissed case over improper service. E.D. Va.: Court Sets Aside Default Lib...

Larue/Tucker v. Brown

›
Larue/Tucker v. Brown STATUS: Appellate Court rules that republication of defamatory content restarts clock for filing a lawsuit. Ariz. ...

Grissom & Thompson v. Browning

›
Grissom & Thompson b. Browning (6/24/2014) STATUS: Defamation claim filed. Tex. Dist.: Law Firm Files Defamation Lawsuit Over Ex-Cl...

John Doe No.1 v. Burke

›
John Doe No.1 v. Burke (May 29, 2014) STATUS: Appeals Court upheld Anti-SLAAP motion. In its first decision to interpret the District o...

Palmer v. KlearGear.com

›
Palmer v. KlearGear.com (May 5, 2014) D.Utah.: Judge: KlearGear Can't Collect $3,500.00 From Couple That Left Negative Online Review ...

Kimzey v. Yelp

›
Kimzey v. Yelp (May 7, 2014) STATUS: Court grants defendant's motion to dismiss. W.D. Wash.: Yelp Wins Another Section 230 Case Tec...

Vazquez v. Buhl

›
Conn. App.: No liability for linking to — and praising — allegedly defamatory article Washington Post (Volokh Conspiracy) The Connecticut ...

Seldon v. Magedson

›
Seldon v. Magedson (April 25, 2014) D. Ariz. Ripoff Report's Latest Section 230 Win Technology & Marketing Law Blog (Eric Goldman...

Thieriot v. Thewrap.com

›
STATUS: Appellate court reverses lower court ruling. Do Online Media Get Treated Like Traditional Media  Under Libel Retraction Statutes? ...

Dancing Deer v. Liles

›
Dancing Deer Mountain v. Liles (March 12, 2014) STATUS: Appeals court ruled that claim will be heard. Or.App.:  Trashing Reception Hall ...

NCDR v. Mauze & Bagby

›
NCDR V. Mauze & Bagby ( March 11, 2014) 5th.Cir.: Texas Law Firm to Face Defamation Claims Courthouse News A Texas law firm will fac...

Neuman v. Liles

›
Neuman v. Liles  (March 12, 2014) STATUS: Court reverses trial court's ruling, allowing defamation claim to be heard. Ore. App.: Onl...

Intihar v. Citizens Information Associates

›
Intihar v. Citizens Information Associates (3/4/14) STATUS: Court rules that website must be given notice. M.D. Fl.: Court Rules Mugshot...

Choyce v. SF Bay Area Independent Media Center

›
UPDATE (11/10/14) :  Court finds in favor of the website. N.D.Cal.: Websites Win $87,000 From Attorney Courthouse News Dionne Choyce sue...

Murray v. Huffington Post

›
Murray v. Huffington Post (October 25, 2013) Coal Baron and Major Ken Cuccinelli Campaign Donor Sues Blogger for Defamation, Invasion of ...

TRG Motor Sports v. The Media Barons

›
TRG Motor Sports v. The Media Barons (9/30/13) Cal.App.: The Unbelievable Parody Site that Sparked a Race Team's Losing Lawsuit Jalop...

Gillon Music'N Celebrations v Ting

›
Gillon Music'N Celebrations v Ting (9/24/13) STATUS: Federal judge rules lawsuit cannot be brought. D.N.J.: Promoter Can't Sue C...

Sanders v. Walsh

›
Sanders v. Walsh  (9/16/13) STATUS: Appellate panel rules against online posters. Cal.App.: Courts Crack Down on Web Posters Playing ...

Bernath v. Tabitha

›
Bernath v. Tabitha (August 26, 2013) STATUS: Yelp gets anti-SLAPP victory. Ore.Cir.: Yelp Gets Another Victory in Anti-SLAPP Lawsuit T...

Budget Van Lines v. Better Business Bureau

›
Budget Van Lines v. Better Business Bureau (8/20/2013) STATUS: Court is allowing lawsuit over comments made on online review site. Cal. ...

Bently Reserve v. Papaliolios

›
Bently Reserve v. Papaliolios (July 30, 2012) STATUS: The appellate court that there was enough evidence to warrant the case to be heard. ...

Commonwealth v. Cox

›
Commonwealth v. Cox. (August 2, 2013) Pa. Super: Facebook Posting that Someone Has Herpes is Criminal Harassment Technology & Marketi...

Small Justice v. Xcentric Ventures

›
Small Justice v. Xcentric Ventures (July 16, 2013) D. Mass.: Attorney Uses Copyright to Attack Unflattering Web National Law Journal Fed...

Braverman v. Yelp

›
Braverman v. Yelp (June 28, 2013) STATUS: Court applied Section 230 to preempt lawsuit. N.Y. Sup.Ct.: Dentist's Defamation Lawsuit A...

Burril v. Nair

›
Burill v. Nair (6/3/13) STATUS: Lawsuit cannot be blocked says court. Cal.App.: Counselor May Sue for Defamatory Remarks Courthouse New...

Stepanov v. Journalism Development Network

›
Stepanov v. Journalism Development Network  (June 12, 2013) Md. Cir.: Court Dismisses Libel Claim Over Money Laundering Articles The co...

Green Tech v. Watchdog.org

›
Green Tech v. Watchdog.org (April 8, 2013) STATUS: Suit filed in Mississippi district court. Green Tech sues Online Watchdog for Libel ...

DueAll Construction v. Smith et al.

›
DueAll Construction v. Smith, et. al (May 16, 2013) STATUS: Complaint filed in Florida Circuit Court. Fla.Cir.: Brandenton Residents Sue...

Schon v. Kozan

›
Schon v. Kozan  (March 18, 2013) STATUS: Complaint filed in Minnesota District Court. Minn.Dist.Ct. Defamation Doesn't Mean Name Ca...

Rakofsky v. Washington Post

›
Rakofsky v. Washington Post (April 29, 2013) STATUS: Opinion delivered on April 29, 2013. N.Y. Sup.: Judge Not Impressed by Rakofsky v....

Arrington v. Allen

›
Arrington v. Allen (May 5, 2013) STATUS: Lawsuit brought on May 5, 2013. W.D.Wash.: Michael Arrington Files Suit Against Jen Allen, All...

Duc Tan v. Le

›
Duc Tan v. Le (May 9, 2013) STATUS: Washington Supreme Court reversed Court of Appeals ruling. Wash. Supreme Court Reinstates $310K Jur...

Med Express v. Nicholls

›
Med Express v. Nicholls (March 25, 2013) STATUS: Judge set date for an oral hearing on a preliminary injunction. Med Express Sues Margi...

Fiddler's Creek Foundation v. Schutt

›
Fiddler's Creek Foundation v. Schutt (January 25, 2013) STATUS: Suit brought in Florida Circuit  Court on January 25, 2013. Fiddler...

Lee v. Makhenivich

›
STATUS: Order given March 27, 2013.   S.D.N.Y.: You Shouldn't Need a Copyright Lawyer to Pick a Dentist Technology & Marketin...

Johnson v. City of Raleigh

›
Johnson v. City of Raleigh (3/29/13) STATUS: Defamation claim dismissed on 3/29/13 D.N.C.: Court Applies Single Publication Rule to Dism...

McGibney v. Moore

›
McGibney v. Moore (October 24, 2012) STATUS:  Judgement entered against defendant on March 8, 2013. Nev. Dist.: Revenge Porn Site Founde...

Brompton Buildings v. Yelp

›
Brompton Buildings v. Yelp (January 31, 2013) Ill.App.: Building Owner Can't Discover the Identity of Tenant Who Writes Bashing Yelp R...

Hingston v. Google

›
Hingston v. Google (12/21/12) STATUS: Complaint filed in California District Court on 12/21/12. C.D.Cal.: Filing Lawsuits in the United ...

Toups et al v. GoDaddy.com et al

›
Toups et al v. GoDaddy.com (1/18/13) New Lawsuit Against "Revenge Porn" Site Also Targets GoDaddy Ars Technica So-called invol...

Bierman & Weier v. Weier & Author Solutions

›
Bierman & Weier v. Weier & Author Solutions (court filed date) Iowa Supreme Court: Internet Publishes Protected from Libel Suits ...

Gordon v. Mediabistro.com

›
UPDATE:  Complaint answered on March 6, 2013. D.C. Sup.: Were Fishbowl's Wendy Wednesday Posts Just a Joke? Washington Post http://w...

Chevaldina v. R.K./ FI Management, Inc.

›
Chevaldina v. R.K./FI Management, Inc., No.3612-3189  (12/14/12) STATUS: Blogger appealing preliminary injunction. Fla.App.: Blogger Ap...

Noriega v. Huffington Post

›
Noriega v. Huffington Post, No. 1:12-cv-2006 ( 12/14/12) STATUS: Complaint filed on 12/14/12. D.D.C.: Huffington Post Facing $3Million L...

LeBlanc v. Skinner

›
LeBlanc v. Skinner No. 8310/08 (12/12/2012) STATUS: Appellate Court rules in favor of defendant. N.Y.App.: Calling Someone a Terrorist O...

Martin v. Daily News

›
Martin v. Daily News, No. 100050/08 (Dec.3, 2012) STATUS: Court grants Defendant's motion for summary judgment. N.Y.Sup.: Court Gran...

Dietz Development v. Perez

›
UPDATE STATUS: Virginia Supreme Court overturns preliminary injunction. Va: Injunction Over Negative Yelp Review Overturned by Virginia...

Shepard v. The Huffington Post

›
UPDATE :  A federal appeals court holds that there was no libel. 8th.Cir.: HuffPo Smearing of Candidate Not Libel, Says Court Lawyers.com...

Spooner v. The Associated Press

›
Spooner v. The Associated Press STATUS: Lawsuit settled in December 2012. NBA Ref & AP Settle Suit Over Reporter's Tweet Minneap...

Gilman v. Spitzer

›
Gilman v. Spitzer (10/1/12) STATUS: Lawsuit dismissed on 10/5/12. S.D.N.Y.:  Federal Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Against Ex-Gov Spitzer Ne...

ZAGG v. Catanach

›
Zagg v. Catanach ( 9/27/12) E.D.Pa.:  Business School Professors May Be Liable for Defamatory Blog Posts Technology & Marketing Law B...

Pippen v. Mont Software

›
Pippen v. Mint Software (9/26/12) STATUS: Lawsuit dismissed. N.D.Ill.:  Pippen Lawsuit, Shot Down by Judge TMZ Pippen sued a ton of me...

›
Kahl v. Warner Brothers Entertainment (9/14/2012) STATUS: Complaint filed on 9/14/2012 for claims including libel and intentional inflicti...

Dillard v. Raycom

›
Dillard v. Raycom Media (8/24/2012) STATUS: Complaint filed on 8/24/2012 in Lauderdale County Court. Fla. Cir.: Complaint: Dillard v. ...

Seaton v. Tripadvisor

›
UPDATE 8/28/13 STATUS:  Federal appeals court says owner cannot sure website over list. 6th.Cir.: Owner of America's Dirtiest Hotel ...

Redmond v. Gawker Media

›
Redmond v. Gawker Media (8/10/2012) STATUS: Court dismisses suit on anti-SLAPP grounds. Cal. App.: Using Links As Citations Helps Gizm...

Ahmed v. Ethiopian Review Inc

›
Ahmed v. Ethiopian Review Inc. (8/6/2012) STATUS : N.D.GA.: Businessman Claims Web Zine Defamed Him Courthouse News A businessman cl...

In re Philadelphia Newspapers

›
In re Philadelphia Newspapers (May 23, 2012) STATUS: Court files Opinion on July 26, 2012 finding article is not a republication. 3d. Ci...

Hadley v. GateHouse Media

›
Hadley v. GateHouse Media (7/10/12) STATUS: Defendant's motion to dismiss granted on 7/10/2012. N.D.Ill.: Yet Another Case Says Sec...

Lesher v. Doescher

›
Lesher v Doescher (April 16, 2012) STATUS: District Court judge grants Defendant's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict. ...

Ziyi v. China Free Press

›
UPDATE:  California Federal Court hearing the defamation lawsuit on January 25, 2013. C.D.Cal.: Crouching Tiger Actress Demands Journalist...

Carreon v. The Oatmeal

›
Carreon v. The Oatmeal  (June 15, 2012) STATUS: Complaint filed on June 15, 2012. N.D.Cal.: FunnyJunk Lawyer Suing the Oatmeal cartooni...

King v. Phoenix New Times LLC

›
King v. Phoenix New Times LLC  (May 25, 2012) STATUS: Complaint filed on May 25, 2012. Arizona Super: Cops Claims New Times Defamed Him...

Vo. v. Opinion Corp

›
Vo. v. Opinion Corp (May 22, 2012) STATUS: Decision given by New York Superior Court on May 22, 2012. N.Y.Sup.Ct.: Pissed Consumer Deni...

Central Basin Municipal Dist. v. Does 1-10

›
Central Basin Municipal Dist. v. Does 1-10 (May 10, 2012) STATUS: Complaint filed on May 10, 2012. Cal.Super.: Water Agency Draws Fire ...

Summit Bank v. Rogers

›
Summit Bank v. Rogers STATUS : Lawsuit dismissed in May 2012. Cal. App.: Court Rejects 1917 Law on Defaming Banks San Francisco Chroni...

Parks v. Vibe Holdings

›
Parks v. Vibe Holdings  (5/22/2012) STATUS: Complaint filed on May 22, 2012. N.D.Ga: Attorney-TV Star Sues Vibe.com Courthouse News ...

Lesher v. Does

›
Lesher v. Does ( 2/3/2009) STATUS: Texas court awards $13.78 million judgment on April 24, 2012. How Should We Measure Damages Over Defa...

W.J.A. v. D.A.

›
W.J.A. v. D.A. (Nov. 7, 2011) STATUS: Court reverses trial court dismissal on May 16, 2012. N.J.: Supreme Court Considers Presumed Dama...

EDrop-Off Chicago v. Burke

›
UPDATE (6/4/12) STATUS: The Electronic Frontier Foundation files for case to stay in California on June 1, 2012. C.D.Cal.: Group Wants B...

Price v. Gannett

›
Price v. Gannett (May 1, 2012) STATUS: Court rules that Topix is protected by Section 230 on May 1, 2012. S.D.W.Va.: Topix Protected by...

Richey v. Walker

›
Richey v. Walter (May 3, 2012) STATUS: Complaint filed on May 3, 2012. GA. Super.:  Party Official Says Blogs Labeled Him Jail Bird Co...

UMG Recordings, Inc. v. Escape Media Group, Inc.

›
UMG Recordings, Inc. v. Escape Media Group, Inc. (March 20, 2012) STATUS: Petition to Enforce Subpoena filed on March 20, 2012. Cal. Su...

Ouelette v. Viacom

›
STATUS: On April 25, 2012, the Judge rejected Plaintiff's 17 USC 512 (f) claim. D. Mont.: 512(f) Plaintiff Can't Get Discovery To ...

In Re BitTorrent Aduly Copyright Infringement Cases

›
STATUS: On May 2, 2012, a NY Federal judge ruled against plaintiffs in several porn copyright cases. E.D.N.Y.: Federal Judge Decries Blizz...

Lewis v. Rapp

›
UPDATE: N.C. Dist.: Court Awards Judge $105k in Libel Case Associated Press Rapp wrote in a blog posting that Lewis' endorsement vio...

American Heritage Capital v. Gonzalez

›
STATUS: On April 14, 2012 the Court granted a fee-short award to Gonzalez including attorney fees, sanctions and additional financial conce...

Brown v. Doe

›
STATUS: Motion to Quash filed on April 6, 2012. Nev. Dist.: Lawsuit Filed Against Anonymous Commenter Las Vegas Review-Journal A reader...

3M Company v. David, et al

›
UPDATE:   Media organizations submit brief stating that D.C. anti-SLAPP should apply. D.C.Cir.:  Media Amicus Brief Argues that D.C. Anti-...

Davis v. Avvo

›
STATUS: Lawsuit dismissed on March 28, 2012. W.D.Wash.: Lawsuit Against Avvo for Lawyer's Profile Dismissed as SLAPP Technology &...

Shrader v. Biddinger

›
Shrader v. Biddinger (Filed August 6, 2010) STATUS : Decision on February 12, 2012 dismissing parts of Shrader's case, along with gran...

Pitale v. Holestine

›
STATUS:  Decision issued on all counts on February 27, 2012. N.D. Ill.: For-profit college, former employee square off in Wikipedia defama...

Ratingz, Inc v. Adrian Philip Thomas, P.A.

›
 STATUS:  The EFF filed suit seeking declaratory relief on February 22, 2012. EFF Files Suit to Block Threats Aimes at Lawyers Rating Site...
›
Home
View web version
Powered by Blogger.